Nicolinni's

Discover authentic Italian cuisine at Nicolinni's in Youngstown, OH. Enjoy favorites like chicken marsala, mozzarella marinara, fettuccine alfredo, and more in a warm, inviting atmosphere. Call +1 330-799-9999 to reserve your table today!

Welcome to Nicolinni's

Taste the Difference.

Nicolinni's
Nicolinni's
Nicolinni's
Nicolinni's

Step into Nicolinni's, a cherished Italian restaurant tucked away at 1912 S Raccoon Rd, Youngstown, OH. This culinary haven brings the warmth of Italy to the heart of Youngstown, inviting food lovers to indulge in mouthwatering dishes. The robust flavors and inviting atmosphere create a perfect setting for families, friends, and all food enthusiasts. Whether you're seeking a cozy dinner or a lively celebration, Nicolinni's combines delicious flavors and a welcoming vibe.

The menu features beloved classics and unique dishes, ensuring every visit is a delightful experience. Make sure to stop by and savor the rich tradition of Italian dining that Nicolinni's offers.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1912 S Raccoon Rd, Youngstown, OH 44515, United States

Phone

+1 330-799-9999

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Nicolinni's
Nicolinni's
Nicolinni's
Nicolinni's

Nicolinni's Italian restaurant holds a special place in Youngstown's vibrant dining scene. Established with a passion for Italian cuisine, it offers an extensive menu that caters to a wide range of tastes. Diners rave about the chicken francese and butternut squash ravioli, showcasing the restaurant's ability to elevate classic flavors. Each plate tells a story of culinary tradition, with recipes that focus on authenticity and quality.

The restaurant's layout accommodates various dining experiences, from intimate dinners to animated family gatherings.

Beyond the main menu, Nicolinni's frequently hosts themed evenings, further celebrating Italian culture. The inviting ambiance is complemented by friendly staff, who ensure every guest feels like part of the family. Nicolinni's also values community connections, often collaborating with local organizations to support initiatives and charities. This commitment to community, paired with a dedication to outstanding service, creates a dining atmosphere that feels familiar and welcoming. Regular patrons often exchange stories and laughter, reinforcing the restaurant's role as a cherished community gathering spot. Each visit to Nicolinni's feels like coming home, where great food meets the spirit of friendship.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-6 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-7:30 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-7:30 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7:30 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8:30 PM

Nicolinni's boasts a diverse menu filled with over 45 delightful options. Each dish showcases fresh ingredients and culinary expertise. Chicken marsala and fettuccine alfredo frequently receive rave reviews from diners. The cozy decor and attentive service enhance the experience, making every meal enjoyable. Guests can also indulge in unique appetizers like stuffed Hungarian peppers and the seafood medley. The restaurant features peak dining hours, especially bustling on Saturday evenings. To avoid crowds, consider visiting during lunch hours or earlier in the week. Nicolinni's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction ensures everyone leaves satisfied. Plus, weekday specials provide great value without compromising taste.

Nicolinni's

Nicolinni's charm extends beyond its delicious food. The exterior invites you in with warm colors and a classic Italian facade, setting the stage for a delightful experience. A patio area provides outdoor seating for al fresco dining, allowing guests to enjoy the fresh Youngstown air. Inside, the restaurant balances a cozy, rustic vibe with modern twists, reflecting both tradition and style. The laughter of friends and families fills the space, highlighting Nicolinni's reputation as a lively dining destination. This combination of inviting ambiance and scenic outdoor options creates a welcoming atmosphere for all.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

We had such a fantastic experience at Niccolini's Italian Restaurant! Our entrees came with a fresh salad and their house-made dressing, which was absolutely phenomenal. The bread they served was soft, warm, and full of flavor. They even kindly brought out a slice of their pizza for us to try, and honestly it was the best pizza I've had in a long time, perfectly flavorful with tons of cheese. The portions on our entrees were huge and overflowing with food. You definitely get your money's worth here. Everything from the service to the food was wonderful. We can't wait to come back again, and I genuinely don't understand how there are any reviews under five stars! I can't wait to bring my entire family here!!

S
Shauna R.

Tried the 2nd branch of Nicolinni's in the area and it did not disappoint. The interiors are not as visually pleasing as the other branch but the food is just extraordinary. The chicken and greens may be one of the best meals I have ever had.

K
Khaled R.

Visiting from Fl and stopped by this quaint Italian spot for dinner with a friend . I chose a fall special that was out of this world!! Chicken AppleJack with butternut squash ravioli. Chef's kiss!! My friend opted for the Hungarian stuffed peppers--very good but definitely spicy! Cannolis for dessert were the perfect ending to our meal.

C
Caroline T.

Nicolinni's food and desert is amazing. They have an awesome staff. The food is not expensive and they give you a lot of food.

L
Lesa W.

Had dinner with my wife here this evening. We ordered greens as an appetizer. Really tiny portion for $11.99. Our entrees were Shrimp and Clams Diablo and Chicken Marsala. Both entrees were delicious. The Shrimp in my entree were gigantic and you got 3 of them. Very generous portions. I really enjoyed the bowl of salad and bread with dipping oil. We're definitely going back. If you want a quiet place then this one won't fit the bill. Really loud in the dining area. Service was top notch. Give them a try you'll like it.

N
Nick A.

delicious!! salad, bread and fried cheese then alfredo with shrimp and scallops!! sooooo good every time we go.

D
Dannie